Frozen Brandy Alexander Recipe with Ice Cream - A Well Seasoned Kitchen (2024)

Brandy Alexanders are a classic co*cktail that’s been around for years, and is a creamy drink comprised of only three ingredients – equal parts of brandy, crème de cacao, and heavy cream.

As the name indicates, the foundation of this timeless luxurious co*cktail is brandy, a distilled spirit derived from grapes or other fermented fruit. Its complex flavor profile, ranging from fruity to floral to spicy, adds depth and character to the drink.

However, rich, velvety crème de cacao, a chocolate liqueur, is really the star ingredient, with its subtle chocolatey undertones. There are two varieties of crème de cacao, dark and white, and either can be used in a Brandy Alexander. – it’s personal preference. Dark crème de cacao provides a deeper, richer chocolate flavor and darker color to the co*cktail, while white crème de cacao imparts a bit lighter, more delicate chocolate taste.

The exact origins of the Brandy Alexander are somewhat ambiguous, but most sources point to the early 1900s as its time of creation. While there are various theories surrounding its specific history, it’s widely believed to have become popular in the aftermath of Prohibition, when spirits like brandy became more readily available.

One popular theory attributes the co*cktail to New York City bartender Troy Alexander, who was said to have created it at Rector’s restaurant, as a tribute to a successful advertising campaign. The story goes that the drink was named after him, adding “brandy” to the name so it wouldn’t be confused with existing the gin-based co*cktail “Alexander.”

For my frozen version of a Brandy Alexander, you’ll need a total of 5 ingredients:

• Vanilla ice cream

• Brandy

• Creme de cacao (white or dark)

• Ice chips (optional)

• Ground or grated nutmeg, for garnish

Type of Ice Cream to Use

Use the best quality vanilla ice cream you can find -it’s a key ingredient. I like Graeter’s Vanilla Bean (I find it in my Kroger grocery store), Haagen-Dazs and Breyers Natural Vanilla brands. Note that Breyers is a softer ice cream and will result in a smoother drink. For a milkshake texture, use a denser ice cream like Graeter’s or Haagan-Dazs.

Best Brandy to Use

Given the limited number of ingredients in this recipe, I think it’s important to use good quality ingredients. However, don’t go buy a top drawer brandy! I like the flavor of cognac (a type of brandy) in brandy alexanders. Select a nice, mid-priced cognac. A widely available, affordable French brand that works well in this recipe is St Remy. It technically isn’t a cognac because it’s from a different region in France, but it’s made by the same process, so it tastes similar.

The only equipment you need to make these dessert co*cktails is a blender, and here’s all you have to do:

1. Process ingredients.
   Place ice cream, brandy and creme de cacao in a blender and process until mixed.
2. Add ice (if desired).
   Add ice (if using) and process until smooth.
3. Garnish and serve (or freeze).
   Sprinkle top with ground nutmeg and serve immediately, or place in an airtight container and freeze (won’t freeze hard due to the alcohol).

“Yum yum! Made a batch last night for my husband’s birthday and they were a huge hit.”

Carol f.

View more comments

Put a personal spin on your Frozen Brandy Alexanders with one of these variations:

• Use chocolate or coffee ice cream instead of vanilla.
• Add a splash of vodka for a White Russian-inspired twist.
• Garnish with cocoa powder instead of (or in addition to) grated nutmeg.

I often serve these Frozen Brandy Alexanders as after-dinner drinks, either alongside or following dessert.

To elevate them from boozy milkshakes to sophisticated dessert co*cktails, the right presentation is essential. Opting for martini or coupe glasses is a must-have for that timeless, elegant look and feel. The grated nutmeg garnish is another key element, adding a touch of color and texture. It’s a subtle yet impactful addition that elevates the overall presentation and experience.

And, if the texture of your Frozen Brandy Alexanders is more like a boozy milkshake, you may want to serve them with a small spoon or straw.